2014

Christina Palavra

Miss Congeniality

2013

Brittany Stenovitch

2012

Olivia Culpo

Miss Universe

2011

Kate McCaughey

2010

Kristina Primavera

2009

Alysha Castonguay

2008

Amy Diaz

Top 15

2007

Danielle Lacourse

1st Runner-Up

2006

Leeann Tingley

Top 10

2005

Allison Paganetti

2004

Sarah Bettencourt

2003

Krisily Kennedy

2002

Janet Sutton

Top 12

2001

Yanaiza Alvarez

Top 10

2000

Heidi St. Pierre

1999

Claire DeSimone

1998

Connie Harrolle

1997

Claudia Jordan

Top 10

1996

Karen Bradley

1995

Jennifer Aubin

Top 12

1994

RayeAnne Johnson

1993

Juli Roach

1992

Yvette Hernandez

1991

Lynne Michael

1990

Susan Lima

1989

Debra Damiano

1988

Cindy Geronda

1987

Lisa Benson

1986

Donna Silva

1985

Dana Wilson

1984

Debbie Mowry

1983

Allegra Hendricks

1982

Peggy McGraw

1981

Patti Reo

1980

Robyn Hall

1979

Theresa Patterson

1978

Sharon Lee McGarry

1977

Susan Carten

1976

Kathleen Confreda

1975

Marice Love

1974

Debra Anne Cerroni

1973

Gayle White

2nd Runner-Up

1972

Jeanne Lemay

1971

Laurie Stahle

1970

Rebecca Galleshaw

1969

Donna Lewis

1968

Betty Lou Whitmore

1967

Nancy Giuliano

1966

Barbara Williams

1965

Paula Farrow

1964

Carol Ann Tantimonico

1963

Rosemary Jane Dickinson

1962

Marilyn Ann Scott

1961

Joan Marie Zeller

1957

Myrna Altieri

1956

Sandra Vozella

1955

Beverly Jansen

1954

Joyce Anne Sandberg

1953

Barbara Rose Deigman

1952

Delores Selinder